Moving your company’s
office can be hazardous to your financial health, if you are not
prepared for what lies ahead. Most managers put in charge of coordinating
a corporate relocation have never lived through the experience
before. How can they know what to expect? The volume of details
that must be attended to is mind-boggling. Mostly, they learn
as they go by making costly mistakes. These mistakes are costly
in terms of both out-of-pocket dollars and lost productivity.
As one such beleaguered manager put it, “The best education
comes with a large tuition bill.” This does not have to
be the case.
The thousands of decisions that face an average
relocation manager resemble a minefield. You simply can’t
see where the hazards are until you step on them. Sadly, there
are an almost unlimited number of ways to make costly mistakes.
We will focus on the seven major areas where the most common mistakes
are made. Then, we will discuss strategies you can use to prevent
these mistakes from happening.
1. Bad Vendor Selections
First, the most common and most costly mistake
is bad vendor selections. There are many vendors you will hire
to help you relocate your office. These include architects, general
contractors, project managers, interior designers, telephone Systems
and services vendors, computer Systems and networking vendors,
cabling installers, security System vendors, furniture System
vendors, and moving companies, just to name the main ones. If
you work for a larger company, the vendors you hire for the move
may total more than 100. If you don’t allow enough time
to properly plan a move, you must make your vendor selections
in haste. Hiring a bad vendor can jeopardize the entire move.
Vendors who don’t deliver on time or as promised can delay
the move, costing thousands in unnecessary expense.
The biggest complaints about vendors are (in
no particular order of importance):
• Didn’t show up on time or begin
when he promised
• Did not return phone calls
• Did not obtain the appropriate permits on time
• Did not apply enough manpower to stay on schedule
• Suffered parts or equipment back-orders that delayed his
completion
• Failed to complete the job on time
• Exceeded his proposed costs through excessive Change Orders
• Did not furnish agreed-upon deliverables (test documentation,
as-builts, etc.)
Selection of competent vendors always seems
easier than it really is. Most novice relocation managers will
resort to the price and three references method of selection.
This means that potential vendors are invited to submit a price
for goods and services. Since it is assumed that all vendors are
created equal, the temptation is to hire the vendor with the lowest
price. Just to cover themselves, relocation managers will also
require three references of satisfied customers who have successfully
used that vendor. Simply by phoning those references and asking
them if they were satisfied with the vendor should yield a risk-free
selection, right? Nothing could be further from the truth! Do
you really believe that a vendor will furnish names of dissatisfied
customers? Vendors will ONLY supply good references. Now, what
do you do?
There are many areas of focus that will help
you find the right vendor, and they go way beyond the price and
three references approach. First, you need to determine the typical
project size and scope in which your potential vendors have the
most experience. You want to match your project as closely as
possible with your vendor’s experience. Does the vendor
work on projects of your size, or do they suit a different size
of customer? What about the scope of the project? Have they performed
many very-similar projects successfully, or is this one a stretch
for them? Is your vendor a specialist in this specific requirement,
or are they a generalist who attempts to satisfy many needs? The
choice is ultimately yours, and there is no right or wrong answer.
Once you have shortened the list of potential
vendors, you can arrange to take a tour of a customer site. This
will give you a good idea of the vendor’s real life experiences.
Some vendors may not be able to set up a tour at all. They either
cant find any satisfied customers, or they cant show any similar
project experience. Either way, this is what you want to find
out now, not after you hire them. By the way, insist that the
customer contact person be present during the tour. You want to
ask the questions. Speaking of questions, you need to arm yourself
with meaningful questions. Too many managers will simply ask the
customer, Are you satisfied? Here are some suggestions of specific
questions to ask that will yield true information about the vendor:
• Did they show up when promised?
• Did they meet all deadlines?
• Did they cause any other vendors to be delayed?
• How far did their final cost exceed their proposal?
• Was their training effective and performed on time?
• Was on-site support or programming performed on time?
• Are you completely satisfied with the quality of work
performed?
• Are you satisfied with the materials/equipment used?
• Has their ongoing service/warranty work met your expectations?
• Will you use this vendor again in the future?
• If you had it to do all over again, would you select this
vendor?
2. Poor Coordination
The second deadly mistake, poor coordination
is responsible for delays and cost overruns. Letting your vendors
run wild without tight supervision is a formula for disaster.
You are in charge. You will run this show. Too often, relocation
managers will allow their architect or general contractor to handle
the coordination issues, and manage the schedule. This usually
results in a schedule that meets their needs, not yours. You have
to hold their feet to the fire.
Why should you coordinate the project? Because
if you dont, you will be the referee for every fight and disagreement
between the various vendors. Any time there are a dozen or more
vendors involved, there are going to be conflicts. Every time
the schedule is amended, ALL of the other vendors are affected.
If you are constantly reacting to these amendments, you will become
unpopular in short order. Rather than playing Solomon, wouldnt
you rather oversee a calm, orderly project?
The vendors hired for a relocation project
usually fall into two broad categories; construction related,
and non-construction related. The construction related vendors
are obvious. The first of these is the architect that designed
the interior space, specified the materials and furnishings to
be used, wrote the RFP to find a construction contractor, and
applied for the permits. Possibly, you hired an interior design
firm that works in conjunction with the architect. Next, the general
contractor will oversee the actual building of the interior space.
He hires and manages all the sub-contractors whose products and
services include electrical, HVAC, plumbing, carpentry, drywall,
carpet, resilient flooring, acoustical ceiling, millwork, paint,
signage, and possibly others. If you have hired a project manager
to oversee the construction project, this person will also fall
into this category. He would be responsible for the timely completion
of the construction project on budget. His effort, however, would
be limited to the construction project.
Not every vendor you hire is directly tied
to the construction project. You will likely be looking for vendors
to provide and install a telephone System, access control security
System, computer networking equipment, communications cabling,
Systems (modular) furniture, telephone services (including dedicated
data lines, ISDN, DSL, and T-1), and a furniture-moving vendor.
While these vendors need to coordinate their efforts to maintain
your project schedule, they are not considered to be construction-related.
And here is where the coordination becomes critical.
Every change in the construction schedule
potentially impacts the non-construction related vendors. If the
general contractor discovers that the carpet you want is back-ordered,
the modular furniture vendor cannot begin installation on time.
The cabling vendor and electrician cant wire the cubicles until
they are installed. The phone and computer vendors cant install
and test their equipment until the cabling is finished. So, you
can see how arbitrary changes made to the schedule would have
a domino affect on every other vendor. You cant allow one of your
vendors to make changes to the schedule, no matter how minor,
until you have assessed the impact on all other vendors. Your
project completion could be delayed beyond the move-in date!
3. Insufficient Staffing
Inadequate supervision or poor coordination
is usually the result of the third deadly mistake that of insufficient
staffing, or the inability (or unwillingness) to delegate tasks.
If you have no help, you cant possibly manage the entire move.
You need an orderly approach to managing the relocation.
First, recognize that you need help. You will
have to recruit employees from within your organization who can
carry part of the load. You will be the big cheese , or move director.
Select the members of your team based on their area of expertise.
These need not be department heads. In fact, most middle and upper
management types are not good choices. They are unaccustomed to
taking direction, and tend to argue with you about your decisions.
Specialized knowledge is the key. You want
team members who have good working knowledge on their particular
area of expertise, and access to certain corporate records. Here
is a short list to get you thinking about the areas of expertise
you will need on your move team:
• Telephone Systems and Services
• Computer Systems and Networking
• Copiers and other Office Machines
• Communications Cabling
• Electronic Security
• Furniture (including modular furniture)
• Warehousing (materials management)
• Postage Meters and other Mail Room equipment
• Printing Services
• Employee Roster
• Customer Lists
• Vendor/Supplier Relationships
• Records Storage and Archiving
• Construction Issues
• Colors and Fabrics
You will not need a team member for each of
the above items. Many of your team members will have multiple
areas of knowledge. For example:
Example #1
Your IT Manager may know computers, networking, phone Systems,
cabling and security Systems well enough to represent these areas
on your team.
Example #2
Your Office Manager may have expertise in furniture, telephone
service, copiers, mailing room equipment, and printing services.
Example #3
Your HR Manager may know all about communications, and will have
access to employee rosters, customer lists and vendor/supplier
lists.
In the three examples above, you have covered
all but a few items. What remains can be divided among your team
members, or defaulted to you, the Supreme Commander.
Select your internal team early, and put them
to work on specific tasks with firm dates for completion. You
will have to set up a standing weekly meeting where everyone reports
on his or her progress. Pick a time for the meeting when interruptions
by phone or pager are less likely. Set an agenda each week, and
stick to it. Set milestones for completion of each task. Have
someone keep minutes of each meeting so there is no confusion
about what was agreed, or about who said what. Dont end the meeting
until everyone is clear about his or her responsibilities for
the next week. Begin each meeting with a review of what was agreed
last week.
After you have established your internal team
and meeting schedule, you will need to appoint or nominate a coordinator
or liaison for each department within your organization. These
are not members of your team, and will not attend the weekly meetings.
They will simply represent their department for planning and coordination
purposes. Just to start you thinking about it, some departments
may include Executive, administration, human resources, product
development, manufacturing, assembly, editorial, copywriting,
marketing, sales, data processing, programming, information technology,
MIS, communications, accounting, finance, customer service, order
entry, fulfillment, installations, delivery, operations, shipping
and receiving, materials management, claims, training, or credit
union.
Your department coordinators will be responsible
for knowing what items are to be moved, trashed, archived, and
warehoused. It is helpful to create a database for the items in
each category. This will come in handy later when you are obtaining
estimates.
Your department coordinators will also be
responsible for the layout of their departments space. This includes
the layout of individual offices and rooms within the space. It
is important to have each office occupant sign off on their office
layout before installing electrical outlets and cabling jacks
on the wrong side of the office.
The department coordinators will have to tell
you exactly where they want to place computer equipment, fax machines,
copiers and printers. This must be known in advance of designing
the electrical and cabling Systems. Many electrical outlets will
need to be dedicated, not shared. You want to know this now, not
after the electrician is sweeping up.
4. Starting Late
The fourth most common mistake is starting
late. An office move takes many months, even after a site has
been selected and a lease has been signed. Too many companies
paint their vendors into a corner by allowing too little time
to prepare a decent proposal, and even less time to deliver or
install the goods and services purchased. A rushed vendor makes
mistakes. Don’t place your move in jeopardy by expecting
miracles.
The larger the organization, the more time
will be required to successfully plan and implement a relocation.
There is no hard and fast rule that tells you exactly when to
begin this long process, but think about all the issues and how
they are interrelated. Each must be completed before the other
can begin. Here is a VERY brief list of the events that must occur,
in chronological order. There are actually over 200 such events
in a typical relocation, but we will not list them all here. This
list is provided just to get you thinking:
• Hire
the architect
• Hire
the broker
• Find
the space
• Negotiate
and sign the lease
• Determine
the move-in date
• Prepare
the floorplans
• Obtain
permits
• Hire
the General Contractor
• Hire
the Project Manager
• Establish
the construction schedule
• Select
your internal move team
• Choose department coordinators
• Hire the telephone System vendor
• Order telephone service and data-lines
• Hire the cabling vendor
• Hire the security System vendor
• Hire the furniture vendor
• Hire the computer Systems vendor
• Send letters to customers and vendors/suppliers
• Order new stationery
• Order new furniture
• Hire the furniture mover
• Order boxes
• Label all items to be moved
• Store/Archive records
• Arrange for trash hauling
• Schedule computer System downtime (back-up)
• Arrange for employee training
• Distribute keys/passcards
• Re-paint company vehicles
Let’s say this is the short list of
events that you will coordinate for your office move. Obviously,
nothing can begin until you find a new space and sign the lease.
But, you must know your space needs pretty well, or you could
make a bad selection. So, the architect might be hired first.
The architect can help you determine whether a particular space
literally fits your rough layout, based on an understanding of
your work flow. Once the move-in date is fixed, its a mad dash
to the finish line. All vendors must squeeze their work into the
time available. If you drag your feet on vendor selection, you
will make this problem worse. If you really squeeze your vendors,
you are betting that nothing will go wrong, and that there will
be no delays or back-orders. This is not a likely scenario. The
time to plan is BEFORE you have selected a space and signed a
lease. How, then, can you estimate the time required in which
everything must be done? Your broker can estimate how long it
will take to find a space, negotiate the lease, and sign it. The
haggling over terms is the big unknown here. Your architect can
help you with a time estimate for the construction project. Permits
can be a big delay.
That’s about as much help as you’ll
get. The vendors you hire, like the telephone and computer vendors
may have long lead times for equipment. You need to know up front
which phone System and computer equipment you will purchase in
order to avoid long lead times (or to know what those lead times
are). The cabling must be done before the computer and telephone
Systems can be installed and tested. As we mentioned earlier,
the cabling is dependent on the timely installation of all modular
furniture, which is dependent on timely installation of the carpeting.
Phone System installation is also dependent on the provision of
services, such as dial tone lines, T-1, ISDN and DSL lines from
your local phone company. If your computer System needs to link
to another remote site, the high-speed data lines must also be
in place before the System can be made operational. Lead times
for some services can be many months.
It is fairly simple to arrange for printing
new stationery or for moving the office furniture, but most other
events are co-dependent. All these interrelated events must be
placed on a big list with dates for completion. As one changes,
many others must change with it. Once the schedule is roughed-in,
make sure there is enough time to conduct a respectable vendor
selection process. As you discover that key dates must move backwards,
this will help you determine the appropriate starting dates. And,
youll probably conclude that there is no such thing as starting
too early.
|
|